i tried clicking the quote icoc, it does refresh the page, but it didn't go the the homepage, it passed different variables in the url. The reason i know that it didn't go back to the homepage is the url has a variable called option=com_fireboard. That is the name of the forum software, its called fireboard.
What i recommend so you don't get a page refresh, is clicking the quick reply icon, its a lot faster and you can can still see the previous post message.
You said you were looking for templates. The best joomla templates can be found at
www.rockettheme.com and
www.templateplazza.com. My website theme is modual_plazza from templateplazza.com. I am not much of a graphic artist, thats why i chose joomla because of some of the cool templates. Plus, I don't want to reinvent the wheel, if someone has already wrote the software use it. A majority of the atv sites are using phpBB or fireboard for their forums, they can be difficult to administer, but if you had to code this yourself you would be looking at months down the road.
Where you get your honeycreek templates, or any of your templates?